Brand strategy
Why Nike Is Struggling: The Simple Story
Nike’s troubles aren’t caused by one lost star or one bad ad. A few big decisions over the last six years slowly weakened the company. Here is what happened, in plain words.
1. Nike stopped selling in other people’s stores
Around 2020, Nike decided to sell more through its own website and stores. That sounds smart, since Nike keeps more money from each sale. But Nike cut ties with long-standing store partners such as DSW and Olympia Sports. Its CEO at the time later admitted the company went too far in this direction.
The problem is that shoppers often find new shoes while walking through a store. When Nike left those shelves, rivals like Hoka and On moved in. Nike’s own online sales also dropped, because fewer people saw its products in the first place.
2. New boss, big changes
In 2024, Nike replaced that CEO with Elliott Hill, a Nike veteran who had spent almost his whole career at the company. His plan is to put sport back at the center. He has:
- Rebuilt the company around individual sports, instead of “men’s, women’s and kids’.” Nike now organizes its teams around key sports instead of those categories.
- Cut jobs. One round removed 2% of staff, over 1,600 jobs, and smaller cuts followed.
- Brought back stronger ties with stores.
3. Marketing: a few misses and less cultural pull
Some recent ads missed the mark. At the Boston Marathon, an outdoor ad implied walkers were merely tolerated, upset disability advocates, and was quickly pulled. For a brand that says everyone with a body is an athlete, that was a bad look.
The bigger issue is that Nike lost touch with the people who shape trends. Running clubs and athletes with big followings now matter a lot, and Hoka and On won them over first. Nike’s share of the running market fell to 22.9% last year.
4. The shoes themselves felt old
Nike leaned heavily on classic styles like the Air Force 1, Dunk and Air Max, while competitors offered newer, performance-focused shoes. Too many old-style pairs piled up, and Nike had to discount them. Hill admitted that sales of Nike’s lifestyle and Jordan streetwear shoes remain weak and lead to discounts.
5. China and tariffs
China used to be Nike’s second-biggest market, and sales there keep falling. In the latest quarter, Greater China fell 12%, or 17% after adjusting for currency changes.
Tariffs (taxes on imported goods) made things worse. Nike’s latest profit also looked better than it really was. Without a one-time tariff refund, its profit per share was 20 cents instead of 72.
6. Are athletes losing trust in Nike?
The truth is more mixed than the headlines.
Signs of trouble:
- One basketball figure said athletes feel Nike has become “transactional”, meaning less like a family.
- Nike has a past problem here. Runners like Allyson Felix said they were financially penalized for getting pregnant, until backlash forced a policy change.
- Lamine Yamal (who left Nike in 2024, not this month) explained his choice this way: he felt stars like Mbappé and Vinícius Júnior blocked his chance to be a main face of the brand, while Adidas gave him space.
Signs it’s exaggerated:
- Even after Mbappé’s exit, Nike and Adidas each have four of the 11 highest-paid players from the World Cup.
- Nike still works with Haaland and Vinícius Júnior, sponsors France, and will take over Germany’s kit contract.
- Mbappé’s exit wasn’t a simple walkout. A source said Nike chose not to renew his deal, and On reportedly gave him equity, a share of the company.
So athletes aren’t storming out in anger. Nike is just easier to leave now, because rivals offer bigger roles and ownership stakes.
7. Signs of recovery
- Sales through partner stores are growing again. Wholesale rose 4% last quarter while Nike’s own direct sales fell 7%.
- North America grew 3%.
- The problems are specific and fixable, and Nike isn’t alone. Lululemon has fallen about 52% this year.
But the share price shows how worried investors still are. The stock closed at a 12-year low in late August and sits far below its 2021 high.
The bottom line
Nike chased short-term profit and data, and lost what made it special: store shelves, local trend-spotters, fresh products and a strong bond with athletes. Elliott Hill is fixing these one by one, but that takes years.
The next big moment is the October 1 earnings report, which will show whether the fix is working.
This is a summary of public news, not investment advice.